Johns Brothers General Store
About Johns Brothers General Store
Johns Brothers General Store brings the spirit of a classic Midwestern mercantile into the heart of historic downtown Connersville, Indiana, offering a shopping experience that feels both welcoming and refreshingly current.
Founded by Brayton and Hunter Johns, the store reflects a genuine passion for helping Central Avenue shine again, creating a place where convenience, character, and community come together.
For customers, that means more than just a place to shop — it means a destination built around easy access, friendly service, and the kind of personal attention that makes everyday errands feel a little more enjoyable.
Whether you’re stopping in for a quick visit or taking advantage of on-site services, Johns Brothers General Store is designed to fit smoothly into your day. Delivery options add even more convenience for customers who want quality and service without the hassle, while credit card and debit card payments make every transaction simple and straightforward.
Accessibility is also a priority, with a wheelchair-accessible car park helping ensure that more people can visit comfortably. Located at 412 Central Ave in Connersville, the store offers a practical, customer-focused experience in a setting full of local charm and historic appeal.
With a perfect 5.00-star rating based on 21 reviews, Johns Brothers General Store has already earned the trust and appreciation of its customers. That strong feedback speaks to the value of a general store done right: a dependable neighborhood business that saves time, serves the community well, and makes shopping feel personal again.
For anyone looking for a high-quality local stop that combines convenience, hospitality, and a clear sense of place, Johns Brothers General Store stands out as a destination worth visiting.
Quality Products
Carefully curated selection
Expert Staff
Friendly, knowledgeable help
Great Value
Competitive pricing always
Happy Customers
Satisfaction guaranteed
What We Offer
Our Collections
Featured Products
Discover our most popular items and best sellers that customers love.
New Arrivals
Fresh inventory arriving regularly. Be the first to see what's new.
Special Offers
Amazing deals and seasonal promotions you won't want to miss.
Our Story
Shop With Confidence
Whether you're looking for something specific or just browsing, our knowledgeable team is here to help you find exactly what you need.
Our Store
Browse our beautiful space
Customer Reviews
What shoppers say about us
Ismail Mithaiwala 2 years ago
Very friendly store! Came by to check out the eclipse from this nice little town. They have a friendly staff and some great banana bread!
Krista Legere year ago
Took my son in there he was 10 at the time they had so much from when I was a child my son could not believe some of the. Stuff moon hard candy old games very friendly and helpful
Ashtyn Siefert 3 years ago
This store is a great addition to connersville! I love that it a collaboration of many different collections from vendors in connersville. Brayton has made a nice rustic atmosphere to help make downtown cool again.
Matt Tinch month ago
Great people and love the store!
Jack Reed 3 years ago
This place is the best!! Just what Connersville needed! Brayton and Hunter do an amazing job filling their store with so many cool/fun items, while also staying true to some of the more classic items that take you back and give you that perfect small town nostalgic feeling. Not to mention it features goods from so many great local businesses, artists, etc. So excited to see what other businesses JBGS inspires to call Connersville home!
SHARON CASTRO 4 months ago
Always find a unique treasure. Love this store!
WVAA 6 months ago
I love shopping at Johns Brothers General Store - reminds me of some of the things we could buy back in the early 1950's ! The place is amazing and has a great selection of groceries and original artist pieces. Thanks for being in downtown Connersville, IN! Great people and lots of wonderful items to buy for all of your shopping needs! Gifts, presents, kitchen goods, yummy food and my favorite is the Seedless Blackrasberry jelly
Chad Cranfill 7 months ago
Johna Brothers General Store is a true local gem. Friendly faces, great service, and everything you need in one stop. Always a pleasure to shop here, highly recommend!
Angie Ropp 4 months ago
Absolutely LOVE Johns Brothers! Locally owned, supports local vendors, specialty items, engages with the community, initiates great events,...overall they are the real deal! Full of great items to buy for any and all occasions!
Cynthia Perez 6 months ago
A wonderful downtown store filled with a variety of merchandise from homemade pies, preserves, handmade items, photography, and so much more. The workers are always helpful and friendly. A family owned business that makes YOU feel like family from the moment you walk in.
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about Johns Brothers General Store
- Wednesday: 10:30 AM-6 PM
- Thursday: 10:30 AM-6 PM
- Friday: 10:30 AM-6 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM-2 PM
- Sunday: Closed
- Monday: Closed
- Tuesday: 10:30 AM-6 PM
Johns Brothers General Store is located at 412 Central Ave, Connersville, IN 47331, IN 47331, United States.
Johns Brothers General Store has a rating of 5.0 out of 5 based on 21 customer reviews.
Johns Brothers General Store features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park.
Johns Brothers General Store features the following from the business: Small Business.
Johns Brothers General Store features the following service options: On-site services, Delivery.
Johns Brothers General Store features the following planning: Quick visit.
Johns Brothers General Store features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards.
Business Features
Highlights & Amenities
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
From the business
- Small Business
Service options
- On-site services
- Delivery
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Visit Our Store
Stop by and see us. We'd love to help you find what you're looking for.
Location
412 Central Ave, ConnersvilleStore Hours
Get In Touch
Have a question? Let us know and we'll get back to you.